No. 2 (76) (2023), THE CARIBBEAN CRISIS IN NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL CONTEXTS
No. 2 (76) (2023)

THE ROLE OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE OF THE UNITED STATES NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL IN RESOLVING THE CUBAN MISSILE CRISIS

THE CARIBBEAN CRISIS IN NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL CONTEXTS
Published 2026-01-26
Maria Moiseevna Sirotinskaya
PDF (Russian)

Keywords

CUBAN MISSILE CRISIS, UNITED STATES NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL,

How to Cite

THE ROLE OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE OF THE UNITED STATES NATIONAL SECURITY COUNCIL IN RESOLVING THE CUBAN MISSILE CRISIS . (2026). The New Historical Bulletin, 2 (76), 58-75. https://nivestnik.su/index.php/journal/article/view/204
ACM ACS APA ABNT Chicago Harvard IEEE MLA Turabian Vancouver AMA

Download Citation

Endnote/Zotero/Mendeley (RIS) BibTeX

Abstract

Role ofthe “Cuban Crisis group” in the Cuban conflict settlement is examined in the article, which is based on the materials of the declassified tapes of the meetings of the Executive Committee of the United States National Security Council (October 16-29, 1962). Although the Cuban crisis itself is rather well explored in domestic historiography, the so-called Kennedy tapes have not been the subject of special analysis. Great attention is paid to the deliberations of EXCOMM, throughout October 19-20, on considering the options to get out of the conflict - by the military operation, including air attack and island invasion, or by naval blockade of Cuba. Executive committee members could be divided, with some degree of conventionality, into “war hawks” - for example, Director of Central Intelligence J. McCone, General M. Taylor, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and “doves”, first of all, Secretary of Defense R. McNamara, Attorney General R. Kennedy. In the end, the latter win. As declassified transcripts show, J. Kennedy listened carefully to the expert opinions, but the final decision about the island blockade was reached by the president himself. In the article importance is also given to the meetings of the “Cuban crisis group” on October 27. It can be concluded that during deliberations on the response letter of J. Kennedy to N.S. Khrushchev, on the contents of negotiations with the Soviet Ambassador A.F. Dobrynin via confidential channel, the president was ultimately persuaded by arguments of R. Kennedy, L. Thompson, Th. Sorensen and some other advisers. Author comes to the conclusion that the mechanism of counselling the U.S. president in the crisis international situation, which was created in October 1962, had proved to be effective. On the whole, the Executive Committee made a significant contribution to the resolution of the Cuban conflict.

PDF (Russian)

References

1. Фурсенко А., Нафтали Т. Безумный риск: Секретная история Кубинского ракетного кризиса 1962 г. Москва, 2006.

2. Фурсенко А.А. Проблемы изучения истории Кубинского кризиса // Холодная война 1945 - 1963 гг. Историческая ретроспектива: Сборник статей /Отв. ред. Н.И. Егорова, А.О. Чубарьян. Москва, 2003. С. 585-596.

Лавренов С.Я., Попов И.М. Советский Союз в локальных войнах и конфликтах. Москва, 2003. C. 213-290.

Есин В.И. Карибский кризис 1962 года: открытые вопросы и наиболее поучительные уроки // Вестник Московского университета. Серия 25: Международные отношения и мировая политика. 2013. № 1. С. 4-12.

3. Ветренко И.А. Игровые технологии при разрешении политических конфликтов // Известия Российского государственного педагогического университета им. А.И. Герцена. 2010. № 123. С. 185-195; Дергачева В.Е., Чернышов Ю.Г. Карибский кризис в политике памяти СССР (России) и США: сравнительная характеристика // Известия Алтайского государственного университета. 2020. № 6 (116). С. 22-28.

4. Агафонова Г.А. Совет национальной безопасности США: История создания и начальный период деятельности 1947 - 1960 гг. Москва, 1977. С. 48, 115.

History of the National Security Council 1947 - 1997. URL: https://irp.fas.org/offdocs/NSChistory.htm#Kennedy.

5. Coleman D. NSC ExComm Meetings, 1962 - 1963. URL: https://historyinpieces.com/research/meetings-excomm-executive-committee-national-security-council.

Аллисон Г., Зеликов Ф. Квинтэссенция решения: На примере Карибского кризиса 1962 года. Пер. с англ. 2-е изд. Москва, 2019. С.408-410.

6. Фурсенко А., Нафтали Т. Безумный риск: Секретная история Кубинского ракетного кризиса 1962 г. Москва, 2006. С. 301-303.

The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis / Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. XI-XII.

Stern Sh.M. Averting "The Final Failure": John F. Kennedy and the Secret Cuban Missile Crisis Meetings. Stanford, 2003. Р. XXIII.

7. Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 665-805.

8. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 54-56.

9. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 51-59, 66-68, 14.

10. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). P. 62.

11. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis / Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 86-81.

Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 668-669.

12. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 131.

13. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 111-112.

14. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 90.

15. Добрынин А.Ф. Сугубо доверительно: Посол в Вашингтоне при шести президентах США (1962 - 1986 гг.). Москва, 1996. С. 50.

Филитов А.М. Германский вопрос: от раскола к объединению. Москва, 1993. С. 180.

16. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 115.

Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 102.

17. Кеннеди Р. 13 дней: Свидетельство о кубинском кризисе. Пер. с англ. Paris, 1969. С. 19.

The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 118-119.

18. Кеннеди Р. 13 дней: Свидетельство о кубинском кризисе. Пер. с англ. Paris, 1969. С. 20.

The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 182.

19. The World on the Brink: John F. Kennedy and the Cuban Missile Crisis. Thirteen Days in October 1962. Day 4. Oct. 19. URL: https://microsites.jfklibrary.org/cmc/oct19.

20. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 189-190.

Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 707.

21. Ефимов Н.Н., Фролов В.С. Карибский кризис 1962 года (новые данные) // Вопросы истории. 2005. № 10. С. 27-30.

Detzer D. The Brink: Cuban Missile Crisis, 1962. New York, 1979. Р. 139-141.

22. Gibson D.R. Talk at the Brink: Deliberation and Decision During the Cuban Missile Crisis. Princeton, 2012. P. 10-11, 21.

23. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 202.

24. Schlesinger A.M., Jr. Robert Kennedy and His Times. New York, 1978. Р. 546-547.

Sorensen Th.S. The Kennedy Legacy. New York; Toronto, 1969. P. 192.

25. Кеннеди Р. 13 дней: Свидетельство о кубинском кризисе. Пер. с англ. Paris, 1969. С. 16, 20-21.

26. Stern Sh.M. Averting ‘The Final Failure': John F. Kennedy and the Secret Cuban Missile Crisis Meetings. Stanford, 2003. P. XXIX-XXX.

27. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 77, 100-101.

Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 673.

Haruya A. Thirteen Days Thirty Years after: "Robert Kennedy and the Cuban Missile Crisis" Revisited // Journal of American & Canadian Studies. 1994. Vol. 12. P. 69-88.

28. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 189.

Minutes of the 505th Meeting of the National Security Council. Washington, October 20, 1962 // Foreign Relations of the United States. 1961 - 1963. Vol. 11. P. 131-132.

29. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 207.

30. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 202.

31. Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 807.

32. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 203.

33. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 205-206.

34. Salinger P. With Kennedy. New York, 1967. Р. 319-320.

35. 30 лет Карибского ракетного кризиса 1962 г. (1962 - 1992): Обмен посланиями между Председателем Совета Министров СССР Н.С. Хрущевым и Президентом США Дж. Кеннеди. 22 октября 1962 г. - 14 декабря 1962 г. // Международная жизнь. 1992. № 6 (спец. вып.). С. 28.

36. Феклисов А. За океаном и на острове: Записки разведчика. Москва, 1994. С. 225.

37. Добрынин А.Ф. Карибский кризис (октябрь 1962 года) // Дипломаты вспоминают: мир глазами ветеранов дипломатической службы. Москва, 1997. С. 219.

38. 30 лет Карибского ракетного кризиса 1962 г. (1962 - 1992): Обмен посланиями между Председателем Совета Министров СССР Н.С. Хрущевым и Президентом США Дж. Кеннеди. 22 октября 1962 г. - 14 декабря 1962 г. // Международная жизнь. 1992. № 6 (спец. вып.). С. 34.

39. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 509, 593.

40. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 500.

Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 775.

41. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 499, 523-524, 546.

Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 773.

42. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 554.

Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 789.

43. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 563.

Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 786.

44. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 550.

45. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 554, 599.

Микоян С.А. Анатомия Карибского кризиса. Москва, 2006. С. 779-780.

46. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 594.

47. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1997). Р. 603-604.

Кеннеди Р. 13 дней. Свидетельство о кубинском кризисе. Пер. с англ. Paris, 1969. С. 68-69.

Frankel M. High Noon in the Cold War: Kennedy, Khrushchev, and the Cuban Missile Crisis. New York, 2004. P. 149-151.

48. The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 605-606.

49. Добрынин А.Ф. Сугубо доверительно: Посол в Вашингтоне при шести президентах США (1962 - 1986 гг.). Москва, 1996. С. 13-14.

The Kennedy Tapes: Inside the White House During the Cuban Missile Crisis /Ed. by E.R. May and Ph.D. Zelikow. Cambridge; London, 2000. 5 pr. (1st ed. 1991). Р. 601-608.

50. Sorensen Th. The Cuban Missile Crisis in Retrospect. Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs, Princeton University. Oct. 5, 2010.

Robert MacNamara Reflects on the Cuban Missile Crisis (2003). URL: https://alphahistory.com/coldwar/robert-mcnamara-reflects-cuban-missile-crisis-2003.

Thompson Sh., J. Cuban Missile Crisis - The Trollope Ploy Revealed. URL: https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/sites/default/files/pdf/intro_to_sorensen_interview.pdf.

51. Stern Sh.M. Averting "The Final Failure": John F. Kennedy and the Secret Cuban Missile Crisis Meetings. Stanford, 2003. Р. XIX.

Gibson D.R. Talk at the Brink: Deliberation and Decision During the Cuban Missile Crisis. Princeton, 2012. P. 12.

52. Sorensen Th.C. Kennedy. New York, 1965. Р. 619.